Author, industry professional and NWS trustee, Allegra Chapman examines the similarities between music and literature when it comes to going independent.
When I first began my writing career, it was not cool to be an independent author. It was seen as a last resort for people who couldn’t get a traditional deal. Now though, some of the most exciting new authors and hottest new releases are independent.
The traditional publishing industry does not serve everyone. We know that certain demographics, backgrounds and identities are heavily represented, whilst others are almost completely absent. The experience of finding an agent, waiting for that agent to find a publisher, working through the slow publication process, and then heading out into the world to promote your book is long and painful. Which makes it, not only undesirable for some, but
financially, psychologically and emotionally unmanageable for many.
I’ve seen it from all sides, having worked as an agent’s assistant, an editor, and a marketer, before becoming a full-time writer and creative coach. I’ve been traditionally published and self-published, and I now run my own independent imprint, Page Against the Machine.
There’s no doubt in my mind that the traditional system is not designed to support people from minoritised backgrounds and identities – myself included.
This isn’t a new story. In the late 1970s, punk rock bands were struggling to gain traction with record labels because they were too different for the mainstream. So they started doing things themselves. Bands like Buzzcocks and The Fall released albums entirely independently, proving that the gatekeepers weren’t necessary. Then, in the 1980s, “indie music” officially became an industry term, with bands like The Smiths, New Order and The Stone Roses building a reputation through underground venues and radio networks, and establishing independent record labels.
Something similar is now happening in literature. Writers who couldn’t fit the established mould the industry required, who didn’t want to submit to the lengthy and restrictive traditional process, or who simply wanted more creative and financial control, are doing it for themselves.
I chose to release my debut novel, Stars That Have People Names, independently. A magical realist, “weird girl lit” novel about being different, the narrative of which flits between reality, dream and fiction, isn’t a straightforward sell to agents looking for neat categories.
And, having spent seven years writing the book, I didn’t want to spend another five or ten years waiting to see if I could actually get it to readers. I wanted it to be seen now, I wanted to start making money from it now, and I wanted to be able to move on to other projects.
Plus, as a queer, neurodivergent woman, I’ve never felt particularly suited to the “traditional” anything.
Independent publishing isn’t for everyone. It can be confusing, there’s a lot on your shoulders, and you have very little support. The reason I set up Page Against the Machine was to give some of that support and guidance to independent authors who don’t want to be all alone in the process. But it’s still a big leap of faith to back yourself and your book.
It’s reassuring and validating to be chosen by an agent and publisher. It opens doors for you, and takes a lot of the financial responsibility off your shoulders. You get free editing, printing and distribution. You’ll probably get a nice advance. It’s worth noting, though, that you’re still
largely on your own when it comes to selling the book. Marketing support is limited, especially for a first-time unknown author.
Independent publishing is a more rebellious choice. It means taking responsibility for, but also control of, all creative decisions, from editing to typesetting to cover design, as well as practical considerations like distribution and retail agreements. You set the timeline and can move much quicker than the traditional industry. You then keep all the profits from your book sales, and you have full authority over its future.
Perhaps most importantly, you get to tell your story in your way, on your own terms. You don’t have to fit into anyone’s box.
So, if you see yourself as more New Order than Status Quo, indie publishing might be for you.
Do you want to make 2027 the year you Write Your Book? Whether you are aiming for traditional or independent publishing, the Write Your Book programme takes you through the whole writing process from defining your core concept, through building a narrative arc and drafting your manuscript, to editing, refining and finishing your book, as well as showing you how to pitch agents and publishers, and how to self-publish, plus how to market your book to readers. Led by author, editor and award-winning coach Allegra Chapman, this 12-month programme begins in January 2027 – and you just might be ready to publish by 2028! Sign up here.
About Allegra Chapman
Allegra Chapman is an author and columnist, whose words have appeared in The i Paper, The Independent, Cosmopolitan, and many more. She is also an AuDHD activitist, and creative coach plus support system for neurodivergent writers and artists. Allegra is the Founder of Page Against the Machine, and a Trustee of New Writing South.


